Research identifies how doctor-patient interactions can increase physical activity
Patients are open to have conversations about physical activity programmes in the community to improve their health, if recommended by their doctor, new research led by the University of St Andrews has found.
The research, funded by the NHS Fife Endowment Fund, investigated the views of both primary care health professionals and patients on potential methods to connect patients to community-based exercise programmes. It also examined potential barriers to such exercise, and what might help patients connect to groups.
The study focused on Scotland’s recreational running network, jogscotland, which is part of scottishathletics, the national governing body for athletics in Scotland. Jogscotland runs jogging sessions in the community, led by mostly volunteer jog leaders.
Connecting primary care patients to such groups fits within the social prescribing initiative which aims to refer patients to a link worker who can connect them to possibilities in the community to improve health outcomes and tackle issues such as obesity.
The research, published in BJGP Open, found three methods of connection: informal passive signposting, informal active signposting and formal prescribing/referral.
Informal passive signposting involved leaflets, posters and short informational videos about the physical activity opportunities in the general practice for patients’ easy access, with little effort from them and health professionals.
Informal active signposting, on the other hand, could involve health professionals having a conversation about physical activity opportunities in the community and giving a leaflet for the patient to follow-up.
Health professionals also described a method where they would refer the patient to an intermediary who could then work with the patient to identify the method of physical activity opportunities that could work for them. Each of these methods involved a different workload either for the patient or the health professional or both.
The study also found that for health professionals, access to resources advising what physical activity options are available in the community and time to seek out this information was a critical barrier for them to have a conversation with their patients.
Lead investigator of the study, Dr Gozde Ozakinci, Senior Lecturer in Health Psychology in the School of Medicine at the University of St Andrews, said: “This study shows the potential of connecting people with physical activity opportunities in the community. There are many programmes run in the community and jogscotland groups are a great example that calls for investigating and trying different methods of connection co-produced with patients, health professionals, and community groups.
“We also showed that patients when they visit their general practice are receptive to the idea of talking about getting more physical activity. This needs to be done in a manner that respects their autonomy to make the decision but also provides a source of motivation if done in the appropriate manner.
“Health professionals need up-to-date and accurate information about community-based programmes that they can signpost their patients to. We established that there are different workloads associated with these methods.”
Many health professionals wondered about whether the patient that they are seeing would be receptive to the idea of jogging groups and this was a major consideration when deciding on raising the issue during a consultation. They also wanted to share the responsibility of promoting physical activity opportunities with wider society and to avoid medicalising these opportunities.
For patients, on the other hand, a conversation with their doctor could be really motivating and provide a ‘push’ to try physical activity in the community. Although there was a dislike about ‘being dictated’ to, patients reported appreciating the opportunity to be linked to tangible opportunities instead of being told ‘you should get more active’.
The paper, ‘Connecting primary care patients to community-based physical activity: a qualitative study of health professions and patient views’ by Sharon Ann Carstairs, Rayna H Rogowsky, Kathryn B Cunningham, Frank Sullivan and Gozde Ozakinci is published in BJGP Open and available online.
Issued by the University of St Andrews Communications Office.